Supporting the journey of motherhood, in style

The Baby Sleep Questions Every Exhausted Parent Wants Answered

Swoop Baby founder Sarah Clifton cuts through the noise around sleep training, night waking, naps and settling, with practical advice for finding an approach that works for your family.

Words by Courtney McIntosh | Photography by Bree Castel

Few topics in early parenthood attract quite as much advice, opinion and, increasingly, anxiety as baby sleep. Wake windows. Nap schedules. Feeding to sleep. Rocking to sleep. White noise. Sleep associations. Independent settling. Sleep training. The sheer volume of information available to parents can make something already challenging feel even more overwhelming.

For Sarah Clifton, founder of baby and toddler sleep consultancy Swoop Baby, that information overload is part of the problem.  “I think there’s so much information out there that it ends up confusing parents rather than helping them,” she says. “They’re not sure which way to turn.”

Sarah’s path to becoming a baby sleep consultant began with her own experience of motherhood, after leaving a successful career in advertising and discovering an unexpected love for the newborn months.

MEET SARAH: Sarah Clifton Loved the Newborn Bubble. Then It Became Her Business.

Sarah also believes fear-based conversations around sleep training can leave parents feeling as though seeking help isn’t an option. Add the realities of modern family life, including parents returning to work while navigating broken nights, and it’s easy to understand why sleep can become such an emotionally loaded part of early parenthood.

So, what actually matters? And how can exhausted parents separate useful advice from all the noise? We asked Sarah to answer some of the baby sleep questions parents find themselves Googling in the middle of the night.

Is there really such a thing as a naturally “good sleeper”?

Yes and no, according to Sarah. “There are definitely babies who are naturally easier, some just have a calmer temperament from day one,” she says.

But she doesn’t believe a baby’s early sleep temperament necessarily determines what sleep will look like forever.

“In my experience sleep is largely a skill, and like any skill it can be taught and it develops with the right foundations, routine and environment.”

Rather than labelling a baby a “bad sleeper”, Sarah encourages parents to consider the habits and associations that may have developed around sleep over time.

“I don’t think any baby is a ‘bad sleeper’ forever,” she says.

When should parents start thinking about healthy sleep habits?

Sarah believes healthy sleep foundations can begin early, but makes an important distinction between establishing foundations and actively sleep training.

“I’m a big believer in establishing healthy sleep foundations early, from day one if you are open to it, which can sometimes negate the need to sleep train down the track altogether,” she says.

When it comes to sleep training specifically, readiness matters.

Sarah says parents need to feel comfortable and genuinely prepared to make a change, particularly because introducing a new approach can mean a few challenging nights while a baby adjusts.

For families considering sleep training, she suggests around four to five months can be an appropriate time to begin, or when the family’s existing approach is no longer working for the parent or baby.

What does “sleep training” actually mean?

For many parents, the term itself can feel loaded. One of the biggest misconceptions Sarah encounters is that sleep training automatically means leaving a baby alone to cry.

“For me, sleep training isn’t one single method,” she explains. “It’s simply teaching your baby the skills to fall asleep and resettle without needing you to do it for them every time.”

There are different ways to approach that process, and Sarah is clear that she doesn’t believe every family should follow the same method.

“It doesn’t have to mean cry it out, and it doesn’t mean being any less loving or responsive as a parent.”

Instead, she describes the process as establishing consistent habits that can help a baby learn to settle and resettle.

Sometimes, she says, relatively simple changes to the sleep environment, feeding and nutrition, or the timing of naps and bedtime can also make a significant difference.

Can you encourage independent sleep and still be a responsive parent?

“Absolutely,” Sarah says. It’s one of the misconceptions she is particularly keen to challenge.

“Encouraging independent sleep doesn’t mean ignoring your baby, it means teaching them a skill while still being there and responding to genuine needs like hunger, discomfort or being unwell.”

Her distinction is simple: “You’re changing how you respond, not whether you respond.”

Sarah also stresses that what responsiveness looks like can differ between families. Some parents will feel more comfortable with a slow, gradual approach to changing sleep habits, while others prefer something clearer and faster.

“There’s no one-size-fits-all approach, and that’s something I really stand by.”

For Sarah, the goal is to find an approach parents feel confident enough to follow consistently.

How important are daytime naps for overnight sleep?

Very, Sarah says. It’s tempting to assume that a baby who hasn’t slept much during the day will be exhausted enough to sleep more soundly overnight, but Sarah says overtiredness can have the opposite effect.

“An overtired baby actually sleeps worse overnight, not better, so getting naps right during the day sets bub up for a much smoother night.”

Rather than looking at bedtime in isolation, Sarah considers the entire 24-hour period when working with families. Daytime and nighttime sleep, she says, are closely connected.

My baby has always been fed or rocked to sleep. How do I change it?

Slowly, if that’s what feels right for you. Sarah recommends gradually reducing the amount of help a baby needs to fall asleep rather than feeling that every sleep association needs to disappear overnight.

“Go slowly and reduce your involvement in small steps rather than all at once,” she says.

That might mean moving from rocking to patting, then sitting beside the cot rather than patting, before gradually creating more space as a baby becomes comfortable with each stage.

Timing matters too. Sarah recommends beginning when life is relatively calm rather than attempting a significant change in the middle of travel or while a baby is unwell.

“Small, consistent steps feel so much gentler for both of you.”

Why does my baby keep waking overnight?

Unfortunately, there isn’t always one simple answer. “It can be so many things,” Sarah says.

Hunger, temperature, overtiredness, developmental changes or a sleep association such as needing to be fed or rocked back to sleep can all contribute to frequent waking.

It’s why Sarah cautions against assuming that every wake-up has the same cause.

Instead, she looks at a baby’s wider routine and circumstances to identify patterns that may explain what’s happening.

How can you tell if a baby is overtired, undertired or actually hungry?

This, Sarah admits, can require a little detective work.

An overtired baby may become increasingly distressed and difficult to settle, with crying, arching or fighting sleep among the cues Sarah looks for.

An undertired baby, on the other hand, may resist going down or take longer to fall asleep without necessarily becoming distressed.

Hunger can present differently again.

“Genuine hunger tends to show up as a strong, consistent feed rather than comfort sucking, and it follows a pattern you can track over time,” she says.

“It takes a bit of detective work, but the patterns are usually there.”

Does the sleep environment really make that much difference?

“So much more than people expect,” Sarah says.

She considers white noise, darkness, temperature and a predictable bedtime routine some of the simplest foundations families can establish.

White noise can help mask household and street sounds, while a dark room can provide a clear cue that it’s time to sleep, something Sarah considers particularly useful for daytime naps.

Temperature is about keeping a baby comfortable, while a consistent bedtime routine helps create predictability around what happens next.

“Getting all four right is honestly one of the easiest wins for families.”

What happens when travel, illness or a change in routine throws everything off?

Don’t panic.

Babies can experience regressions after disruption, but Sarah says previously established sleep habits aren’t necessarily lost.

“Babies can regress quickly, but the good news is they usually bounce back just as quickly if you get back to the routine and the skills they’ve already learnt.”

Her advice is to return to the approach that was working before the disruption and allow a little time for things to settle again.

“I always tell parents not to panic over a wobble.”

So, what matters most when choosing an approach to sleep?

Perhaps surprisingly for someone whose career is built around baby sleep, Sarah’s answer isn’t a particular routine or method.

It’s finding something that works for your family.

Some parents want a gentle, gradual approach. Others feel more comfortable making a clearer change over a shorter period. Babies have different temperaments, families have different circumstances and parents have different boundaries around what feels right.

Sarah sees her role as helping families identify the approach they will actually feel comfortable implementing.

“Consistency is what makes the difference, not the method itself.”

And if you’re reading this after another broken night, wondering whether everyone else has somehow figured out something you haven’t, Sarah has one final piece of advice.

“You are not failing, and you don’t have to do this alone.”

Sleep deprivation, she says, can be one of the most challenging parts of parenthood, and there is no prize for silently pushing through when you need help.

“Reach out for support, whether that’s a partner, a friend or a professional.”

And let go of the expectation that every nap, bedtime or night needs to go perfectly.

“Consistency over a few weeks matters far more than getting every night right,” Sarah says. “It can take time, but if everyone is safe, fed and loved, you are winning.”

 

Need some extra support with sleep?

Sarah and the Swoop Baby team offer personalised baby and toddler sleep support for families looking for help with settling, routines and sleep challenges. Learn more or get in touch with Sarah via Swoop Baby, or follow Swoop Baby on Instagram for more sleep advice and support.

RECOMMENDED READS